Northern Burlington junior Liliah Gordon, Mainland junior Sofia Day, Ocean City junior Maeve Smith, Cherokee senior Kerry O’Day and Paul VI senior Shaelan McNally aren’t teammates, but they combined to make some history Saturday on the rolling hills at Holmdel County Park.
Gordon, Day, Smith, O’Day and McNally became the fastest quintet of South Jersey runners ever in the same race at Holmdel, home of the girls Meet of Champions and state meet for 51 years.
We wrote earlier about Gordon’s 5th-place finish – you can read about that here – but what made this a unique race in Meet of Champions history is that five South Jersey girls broke 19 minutes in the same race.
And they all ran well under 19 minutes.
Day placed 7th with a Holmdel PR of 18:33.64, Smith ran 18:41.37 for 9th place, O’Day took 10th with a Holmdel best of 18:43.56 and McNally ran 18:50.25 for 11th place, also a Holmdel best for her.
Day’s time is No. 2 in Atlantic County history, behind Alyssa Aldridge’s 17:55 to win the 2016 Meet of Champions. Her previous Holmdel best was an 18:49 at the 2021 Meet of Champions. Day now ranks 17th on the all-time South Jersey Holmdel list.
Smith’s 9th-place finish was the best by an Ocean City girl in nine years, since Devin Grisbaum won the 2014 race. She’s the first Ocean City underclassman with a top-10 finish since Brittany Sedberry won the 2004 race. Smith ran slightly faster at states with an 18:33, which places her in a virtual tie with Day in that No. 17 spot.
O’Day also ran slightly faster at states, but she’s now No. 2 on the all-time Cherokee list behind Megan Lacy’s 17:55 in 2010 and she’s No. 4 in Burlington County history, behind Lacy, Gordon and Shawnee’s Casey Doyle [18:38 in 2007]. O’Day is No. 23 on the all-time South Jersey list.
And McNally ran a Holmdel PR, breaking her previous best on the hilly, winding 5,000-meter Holmdel course by five seconds. She ran 18:56 at the 2021 Meet of Champions.
South Jersey came very close to having five girls under 18 minutes 14 years ago, when Chelsea Ley of Kingsway, Megan Venables of Highland and future Olympian Marielle Hall of Haddonfield swept the top three spots in the 2009 race, Ley in 17:55.16, Venables in 18:00.09 and Hall in 18:16.48. Lacy ran 18:47.84 for 7th and Lenape’s Caitlin Orr, who now coaches at Lenape, came across in 12th 19:00.18, just missing sub-19.
The first South Jersey girl to break 19 minutes at Holmdel was Woodstown’s Jamie Weisgerber, who won the state Group 2 meet in 1994 in 18:50.
It wasn’t until 2003 that two South Jersey girls broke 19 minutes in the same race. That was Sedberry – who ran 18:42 to win the race and Highland’s Arianna McKinney, who ran 18:58 for 2nd place.
One year later was the first time three South Jersey girls broke 19: Sedberry in 18:11 with another win, Wright in 18:21 for 2nd and Cherokee’s Lisa Burkholder with an 18:52 for 9th.
And then 2009, with Ley, Venables, Hall and Lacy, was the first year four girls broke 19.
Gordon, Day and Smith were the top three juniors in the race Saturday, and Cherokee’s Megan Niglio [19:17] and Schalick’s Jordan Hadfield [19:25] were the 7th- and 8th-fastest juniors.
Also under 20 Saturday: Williamstown senior Alyssa Boucher [28th in 19:32], Mainland Regional senior Gillian Lovett [30th in 19:36], Haddonfield sophomore Riley Austin [31st in 19:39], Ava Thomas [32nd in 19:40] and Sterling junior Jonalee Adames [35th in 19:43].
Here’s a look at the all-time South Jersey sub-19 list at Holmdel. Please forward corrections and omissions to me in the comment section!
17:28 … Megan Venables [Highland Reg.], 2010 Group 3
17:40 … Michelle Rowen [Washington Twp.], 1982 Meet of Champions
17:44 … Chelsea Ley [Kingsway], 2008 Shore Coaches
17:45 … Briana Gess [Haddonfield], 2013 Meet of Champions
17:55 … Megan Lacy [Cherokee], 2010 Group 4
17:55 … Alyssa Aldridge [Mainland], 2016 Meet of Champions
18:08 … Holly Bischof [Bishop Eustace], 2010 Meet of Champions
18:12 … Brittany Sedberry [Ocean City], 2004 Meet of Champions
18:14 … Liliah Gordon [Northern Burlington], 2023 Group 3
18:16 … Marielle Hall [Haddonfield], 2009 Meet of Champions
18:18 … Theresa Cattuna [Cherry Hill East], 2006 Meet of Champions
18:20 … Devin Grisbaum [Ocean City], 2014 Meet of Champions
18:22 … Vanessa Wright [Haddonfield], 2004 Meet of Champions
18:27 … Erin Donohue [Haddonfield], 1998 Meet of Champions
18:28 … Grace Yoon [Cherry Hill East], 2016 Group 4
18:29 … Rachel Vick [Kingsway], 2016 Group 4
18:33 … Maeve Smith [Ocean City], 2023 Group 3
18:34 … Sofia Day [Mainland Regional], 2023 Meet of Champions
18:38 … Casey Doyle [Shawnee], 2007 Meet of Champions
18:40 … Mindy Rowand [Sterling], 1984 Meet of Champions
18:40 … Dina Iacone [Washington Twp.], 2011 Shore Coaches
18:41 … Shelby Cain [Haddonfield], 2011 Group 2
18:41 … Kerry O’Day [Cherokee], 2023 Meet of Champions
18:43 … Amanda Goetschius [Delsea], 2006 Meet of Champions
18:43 … Nicole Clifford [Cherokee], 2021 Meet of Champions
18:44 … Arianna McKinney [Highland], 2003 Shore Coaches
18:48 … Grace Wassell [Highland], 2021 Meet of Champions
18:49 … Meghan Malloy [Haddonfield], 2011 Meet of Champions
18:49 … Mara Schiffhauer [Seneca], 2013 Meet of Champions
18:49 … Olivia Shafer [Egg Harbor Twp.], 2019 Meet of Champions
18:50 … Dawn Cody [Paul VI], 1982 Meet of Champions
18:50 … Jamie Weisgerber [Woodstown], 1994 Group 2
18:50 … Sarah Naticchia [Haddonfield], 2020 Holmdel Invitational
18:51 … Shaelan McNally [Paul VI], 2023 Meet of Champions
18:52 … Lisa Burkholder [Cherokee], 2004 Meet of Champions
18:53 … Renee Tomlin [Ocean City], 2005 Meet of Champions
18:54 … Madison Coppolino [Sterling], 2017 Meet of Champions
18:57 … Lori Watson [Cherry Hill East], 1983 Meet of Champions
18:58 … Abbey Hartman [Ocean City], 1996 Meet of Champions
18:59 … Monique Purcell [Holy Spirit], 1978 Group 3
18:59 … Wendy Westphal [Highland], 1982 Meet of Championjs
18:59 … Kara Bonner [Shawnee,], 2015 Group 4
18:59 … Alyssa Condell [Timber Creek], 2016 Meet of Champions